Pillar 5Enablement Produces: Stakeholder Engagement Plan

AI Engagement & Collaboration

Make AI something the campus does with people, not to them.

Aligns withOECD AI PrinciplesNIST · Govern

The idea

This pillar is about how people take part in shaping AI: stakeholder engagement, communities of practice, partnerships, and the shared-governance coordination higher education requires. It targets a common failure: a technically sound strategy that stalls because faculty, staff, and students were handed conclusions instead of helping form them.

It's made concrete through structured channels (senate consultation, student input, staff forums) that feed actual decisions, at least one community of practice, and outside partnerships that extend the institution's capacity. The test isn't whether a forum was held but whether stakeholder input changed a decision. It works alongside Campus Readiness (Pillar 6), which builds the literacy people need to engage, and Roles & Responsibilities (Pillar 7), which assigns ownership.

Why it matters

In higher education, legitimacy is a precondition: faculty can withhold the buy-in any AI initiative needs. Engagement is also how literacy spreads, how shadow AI surfaces (people say what they're using when they trust the conversation), and how problems get caught early, while they're still cheap to fix.

Small-unit formBorrow: join a campus community of practice or pair with a peer unit.

Engagement & collaboration

This pillar works on two fronts: how people participate in shaping AI, and how the institution partners to extend its capacity. The participation and partnership work below is what keeps AI something the campus does with people, not to them. How proficient people become is built under Campus Readiness (Pillar 6).

How people participate, and how the institution partners

Engagement and collaboration is the frame. This pillar works on how people participate in shaping AI and how the institution partners, internally and externally, to extend its reach and keep practice current.

Inclusive participation & shared governance

Standing channels for senate consultation, student input, and staff forums that feed actual decisions, so people help form conclusions rather than receive them.

Communities of practice

Standing peer groups that share what's working across units, turning isolated experiments into shared institutional learning.

Internal partnerships

Coordination across the teaching center, IT, the library, HR, and student affairs so effort compounds instead of duplicating.

External partnerships

Relationships with peer institutions, consortia, vendors, and community organizations that extend capacity and keep practice current.

How you can tell

When it's working
  • Stakeholders engage from knowledge, not apprehension, drawing on the role-based literacy built under Readiness (Pillar 6).
  • There are standing channels for senate, student, and staff input that feed actual decisions.
  • At least one active community of practice shares working approaches across units.
  • You can name a decision that changed because of stakeholder input.
When it's missing
  • AI 'training' is one generic webinar that speaks to no one in particular.
  • Decisions are announced, not consulted; faculty learn of AI policy after it's set.
  • People experiment in isolation and repeatedly solve the same problems.
  • Engagement is theater, input is collected and ignored.

How to operationalize it

Rate your campus

Each practice is something you can build, assign, and evidence, with a first move, an owner, and what proof looks like. Move one practice up one level at a time.

The five levels: 1 Initial · 2 Emerging · 3 Defined · 4 Managed · 5 Optimizing. Each practice describes levels 1, 3, and 5. Level 2, Emerging: some level-3 behavior exists in pockets, but informally. Level 4, Managed: level-3 behavior is applied consistently, measured, and reviewed on a set cadence.

1

Stakeholder map & engagement plan

A living map of who is affected and a plan for how each group is informed, consulted, or co-designing.

Not yet rated
1InitialEngagement is reactive, stakeholders hear about decisions after they're made.
2EmergingGood practice exists in pockets, but it is informal and has not been institutionalized.
3DefinedA stakeholder map and engagement plan exist, with channels and cadence per group.
4ManagedThe practice is applied consistently, measured, and reviewed on a defined cadence.
5OptimizingEngagement effectiveness is measured and the plan is revised; affected groups report feeling heard.
Next moves
  1. Map stakeholders by interest and impact using the Pillar 5 template.
  2. Assign a channel, cadence, and owner for each group.
  3. Close the loop: report back what changed because of input.
Who owns it

AI lead · Communications

Evidence it exists
  • Stakeholder map
  • Engagement calendar
  • You-said-we-did reports
2

Shared governance integration

Faculty senate, staff council, and student government have defined roles in AI decisions.

Not yet rated
1InitialShared governance is bypassed; AI decisions arrive as faits accomplis.
2EmergingGood practice exists in pockets, but it is informal and has not been institutionalized.
3DefinedDefined consultation points exist, senate review of academic AI policy, student voice on student-facing systems.
4ManagedThe practice is applied consistently, measured, and reviewed on a defined cadence.
5OptimizingShared governance bodies have delegated roles in annual review cycles and report satisfaction with the process.
Next moves
  1. Define which AI decisions require senate, staff council, or student government consultation.
  2. Give the faculty senate a standing role in the annual review of course-level AI expectations.
  3. Seat student representatives on the governance body with full standing.
Who owns it

Provost · Senate leadership

Evidence it exists
  • Consultation matrix
  • Senate review records
  • Student appointment letters
3

Feedback & innovation intake

A front door for faculty, staff, and students to propose AI use cases and raise concerns.

Not yet rated
1InitialIdeas and concerns travel by hallway conversation and die there.
2EmergingGood practice exists in pockets, but it is informal and has not been institutionalized.
3DefinedA published intake process routes proposals to governance review and concerns to a named owner.
4ManagedThe practice is applied consistently, measured, and reviewed on a defined cadence.
5OptimizingIntake volume, decisions, and turnaround are tracked; proposers get reasoned answers.
Next moves
  1. Publish one intake form for proposals and concerns with a defined triage path.
  2. Commit to response-time standards and reasoned decisions.
  3. Report intake themes to the governance body each term.
Who owns it

AI governance body

Evidence it exists
  • Intake form & triage workflow
  • Decision log with turnaround times
  • Termly theme reports
4

Communities of practice

Peer learning networks organized by functional area, connected to enablement resources.

Not yet rated
1InitialPractitioners experiment alone; lessons aren't shared.
2EmergingGood practice exists in pockets, but it is informal and has not been institutionalized.
3DefinedCommunities of practice exist by functional area with institutional support (time, space, sponsorship).
4ManagedThe practice is applied consistently, measured, and reviewed on a defined cadence.
5OptimizingCoPs feed documented patterns into guidance and training; participation is recognized in workload.
Next moves
  1. Charter CoPs for the highest-activity areas (teaching, advising, IT, research).
  2. Give each a sponsor, a venue, and a connection to the enablement budget.
  3. Harvest patterns from CoPs into official guidance twice a year.
Who owns it

HR / Professional development · Functional leads

Evidence it exists
  • CoP rosters
  • Meeting cadence
  • Patterns adopted into guidance

In practice

Worked example

From announcement to co-design

A provost's office drafts an AI teaching policy and sends it to the senate for a vote; the senate, blindsided, tables it and trust erodes. Under this pillar the sequence inverts: a faculty community of practice surfaces real classroom dilemmas, a working group co-drafts guidance, and role-based workshops build literacy before any vote. The policy that finally moves is stronger and passes, because the people bound by it helped write it, and the engagement channel becomes the early-warning system for the next issue.

Watch for

  • Letting external partnerships outrun the internal engagement and shared governance that should shape them.
  • Consultation that gathers input after the decision is effectively made.
  • Ignoring shared governance until a vote forces the conversation.

Readiness & maturity questions

Readiness asks: are we prepared? Use these to surface blind spots before you build. Every “no” shows where the work is. Representative prompts for reflection, not a scored test. For the scored version, use the Maturity Assessment.

AI Community of Practice
  1. Has a formal AI Community of Practice (CoP) been established?
  2. Are diverse stakeholders (faculty, staff, students) invited?
  3. Is the CoP's purpose and scope clearly defined?
  4. Are meeting schedules and participation expectations communicated?
  5. Is leadership sponsoring or endorsing the CoP?
  6. Are marginalized or underrepresented groups intentionally included?
  7. Are there clear feedback loops to decision-makers?
  8. Does the CoP have logistical and administrative support?
  9. Are goals aligned with institutional AI priorities?
  10. Are CoP activities documented and shared?
Partnerships & External Collaboration
  1. Have we mapped existing or potential AI partners (vendors, institutions)?
  2. Are we clear on goals and expectations for external collaborations?
  3. Do we have guiding principles or MOUs for AI ethics in partnerships?
  4. Are internal teams aligned before external engagements begin?
  5. Are we engaging nonprofits, civic orgs, or diverse community partners?
  6. Are partnership activities reviewed for mission alignment?
  7. Is there a vetting process for AI vendors?
  8. Do contracts include data privacy, security, and IP terms?
  9. Are faculty and students involved in partnership formation?
  10. Is there a contact person or office responsible for AI partnerships?

Apply this pillar